The popularity of organic wines is on the rise, with an increase of about 15% in organic wine consumption in the last seven years.
If you’re an organic wine drinker, you might want to consider joining an organic wine club. These types of subscriptions are a great way to discover new natural wines with no additives to add to your repertoire.
In this guide, we’ll go over the best organic wine clubs in the United States at the moment. We’ll also take a look at how to choose which organic wine club is best for your preferences.
Quick comparison table
Contents
Best organic wine clubs
While there are plenty of wine clubs that offer organic wines, only a few specialize in these types of wines specifically.
Here are some of the top organic wine clubs to be aware of if you love drinking sustainable blends.
1. Nakes Wines Organic Wine Subscription
While you can buy retail wine from Naked Wines, their Angel membership is what most people choose to get a regular shipment of great organic wines.
The Angel membership gives you access to a discount of up to 30% on retail prices. It works by billing you a fee each month, which can go towards a monthly shipment or be saved for future purchases.
This means that Naked Wines’ memberships are super flexible, making them great for those who don’t necessarily want a regular shipment every single month. If you don’t want to buy a case of wine, just hang onto your cash until next month.
In terms of the wines themselves, Naked Wines has a large selection of organic wines available. They’re a great choice if you’re already familiar with organic blends and want a way to try things you wouldn’t find in the grocery store.
Another perk of Naked Wines is that their per bottle price tends to be fairly low. Combine that with their special introductory discounts that are often available, and you’ve got a good membership for those on a budget.
The one downside to this subscription is that popular wines get purchased quickly and don’t always come back in stock very quickly. If you have a favorite organic Naked Wines blend, it can be tough to get on a regular basis.
Overall value
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2. Vinesse Organic Wine Subscription
Vinesse is a global wine club that offers a huge selection from different wineries around the world. They especially like to support and promote small, local vineyards, so you can try some pretty unique organic wines from this company.
Vinesse has an introductory offer which is typically about 50% off their regular membership price. This offer includes eight bottles of wine, which works out to be around $15 each.
Although Vinesse features wines from around the world, the majority of its blends come from California. Since these are mostly small wineries, a lot of them will still be unfamiliar, even if you regularly drink California wine.
Even though the US only produces about 2% of the world’s organic wine, a good chunk of them come from California. So, you don’t have to worry about not being able to find natural blends from Vinesse.
One of the best things about Vinesse is that you get to rate your wines once they arrive. By rating your wines, the company is better able to tailor your next subscription so that you keep getting wines that you enjoy.
This is especially helpful for organic wine drinkers, because the flavors tend to be a bit more nuanced. With the rating system, you can really hone in on the specific tasting notes you enjoy.
There are four different subscriptions that you can pick from, including monthly, bimonthly, and quarterly. The flexibility is great for those who want to mix up how often they receive their subscription box.
While there aren’t many downsides to Vinesse, one thing to note is that this membership cannot be gifted. If you want to surprise a friend or family member with a wine membership through Vinesse, the best you’ll be able to do is give them a gift card.
Overall value
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
3. Plonk Organic Wine Subscription
Plonk is an organic wine club that’s a bit on the pricier end. You have to pay sales tax in your state, and since the wine comes out to higher than average grocery store prices ($15-$20), this isn’t necessarily the best club for those on a budget.
What’s great about Plonk, however, is that they offer exclusively organic and sustainably-grown wines. You won’t have to pick through their catalog to make sure you’re coming up with organic blends.
In addition to this, Plonk offers a bit of flexibility with their shipments. You can choose between monthly, bimonthly, and quarterly plans. And, you can choose between receiving shipments of four bottles and twelve bottles.
Whether you drink a ton of wine or don’t get through much in a month, Plonk has got plans for you. Plus, you can always adjust your shipment options if anything changes. This flexibility is definitely a perk, especially if you’re not used to purchasing wine through a wine club.
Another great thing about Plonk is that their wines tend to be high-quality, so they’re a good pick if you’ve got a relatively refined palette.
While there are plenty of good things to say about Plonk, they do have one major downside: their cancellation policy.
Plonk offers pay-per-shipment plans and prepaid plans (offered at a discount). If you go for a prepaid plan, you won’t be able to cancel anytime. You’ll be locked into the plan until your membership ends.
So, for example, if you paid for a plan for a full year, you won’t be able to cancel until the year is up.
Still, you can get around this by just choosing to pay for your plan with each shipment. It’ll just end up being a bit pricier for an already slightly costly wine club.
Overall value
⭐⭐⭐⭐
4. Cellars Wine Club Organic Wine Subscription
Cellars Wine Club is a wine club subscription service that’s highly customized. They’ve got tons of subscription options with varied shipment frequency and bottle numbers.
Unlike many other wine subscriptions on the market, Cellars Wine Club has different subscriptions based on your wine preferences.
For example, you can choose organic, red, sparkling, or rosé subscriptions that focus only on these types of organic wine.
The one downside to this system is that they don’t have a white wine subscription option. While you can get white wines in one of their other subscriptions, there’s no membership dedicated to whites only. So, if you’re a white-wine drinker, this probably isn’t the wine club for you.
Still, even though it might not be great for white wine lovers, Cellars Wine Club has an exhaustive list of wines. There are blends from tons of different regions, so organic wine drinkers will get the chance to try a huge variety of different flavors.
The wine club isn’t cheap, however, with their most expensive package costing upwards of $300 and their per bottle price set at around $25-$30. If you’re on a budget, these prices can make this wine a bit inaccessible.
Despite the high price, the quality of the wine is fantastic. You’ll get some pretty unique flavor profiles, and also get to experience tasting notes you’re not likely to find with other subscriptions.
Overall value
⭐⭐⭐⭐
5. Winc Organic Wine Subscription
Winc focuses on natural, organic, and indie wines that you won’t find in your average grocery store.
This is a personalized wine club that uses a short quiz to determine what your wine preferences are. There’s even a part of the quiz where you can select if you only want wines with no additives or not. If you check this option, you’ll only be shown organic wines, saving you time having to hunt through the site’s offerings on your own.
Winc has an introductory offer that’s about 25% off the normal price of your wine subscription. This offer gets you six bottles of wine, making it a great way to get used to the brand without committing to a membership that costs a ton of money.
In terms of the range of bottles available, Winc isn’t as varied as some other organic wine clubs out there. This is especially true for their specialty (ie vegan, organic, or sugar-free) wines.
Still, there are enough different wines that you should be able to try at least a few new bottles without repeating. And, since they’re always adding new partners, their list of available wines is constantly growing.
Besides the limited selection, the only other issue with Winc is that it’s not available in all states. Currently, these states cannot receive Winc subscriptions:
- Alabama
- Delaware
- Arkansas
- Mississippi
- Hawaii
- Michigan
- Kentucky
- South Dakota
- New Jersey
- Utah
That’s only 10/50 states, however, so it’s not likely to be a dealbreaker for most wine club members.
Overall value
⭐⭐⭐⭐
How to choose a good organic wine club
Now that you’re aware of some of the best organic wine clubs available at the moment, let’s talk about how to pick which one is right for you.
Here are a couple of things to keep in mind when picking an organic wine club.
Quantity
There are two things to think about in terms of quantity when choosing an organic wine subscription:
- The number of organic wines available
- The number of bottles in a shipment
Because organic wine is a bit harder to come by, not all wine clubs have a huge selection of these types of wine to choose from. This can mean you wind up repeating wines rather than exploring new varieties.
On the other hand, if you know where to look, there are some clubs that have huge selections of organic wines. These clubs also generally get new wines in frequently, so their selection of organic wines is constantly growing.
Another thing to think about in terms of quantity is how many bottles come in a shipment. Most wine clubs will send you a minimum of four bottles per shipment. At the same time, there are those that will send out shipments of up to twelve bottles.
If you live in a big household, regularly entertain, or drink a lot of wine, a four bottle shipment just might not cut it. Those four bottles can go in just a couple of nights, leaving you without anything for the rest of the month.
On the other hand, if you’re more of an occasional drinker, you probably don’t need to receive twelve bottles in a shipment.
Think about how many people will be drinking the wine and how often you partake. This can help you choose an organic wine shipment that makes sense in terms of quantity.
Quality
Finding high-quality organic wine is important. Because organic wine doesn’t have flavor additives, the taste tends to be a bit more nuanced. When an organic wine is poorly made, you can wind up with a drink that tastes more like grape juice than anything else.
Some wine clubs offer higher quality blends than others. For example, Naked Wines tends to have a higher selection of wines, but the wines are of lower quality.
On the other hand, Winc’s selection is on the smaller side, but the wine tends to be a bit higher quality.
If you don’t mind mid-range wines, you could settle for a more affordable club with a broader range. But, if you’ve been in the wine-tasting game for a while, you may find a slightly more select club like Plonk works better for you.
Think about what type of quality you’re looking for in order to choose a wine club that fits your needs and tastes.
Location
Location is a big factor in choosing a wine club, for two reasons:
Some wine clubs give perks to members who live in the same state or country
Not all wine clubs ship to every state
Going off the first point, clubs like California Wine Club offer special benefits to those who live in California. Members get access to VIP tours and tastings at any of the wineries associated with the club.
However, if you live in Pennsylvania for example and are part of this wine club, it might not make sense to fly to California just to take advantage of these perks.
Another thing to consider in terms of location is liquor laws. Liquor laws in the United States can get pretty strict, which means depending on where the wine club is located, they may have restrictions on what states they can ship to.
Some clubs will only ship domestically within their own state or to a limited list of surrounding states. Other clubs will ship just about anywhere in the US.
Make sure to look into the wine club you’re considering and double-check that they offer shipping to your state.
Frequency
Some wine clubs ship more frequently than others. If you’ve read our guide on the best red wine clubs, you know that some clubs ship every three months and others ship every month. 
If you’re not a big wine drinker, you probably don’t need to receive multiple bottles of wine every month. In that case, a more infrequent shipment plan could work for you.
On the other hand, if you get through a good amount of wine each month, you might want to opt for a company that offers more regular shipments.
Think about your lifestyle and how often you drink wine. This will help you figure out how frequently you need shipments
Reputation
You have to be particularly careful about finding an organic wine club because even though some clubs claim to be organic, not all are.
For the average buyer, this can make it a bit tough to figure out which wine clubs are worth trying and which are not.
Before signing up for any organic wine club, make sure to do some research. Check sites like Better Business Bureau and Trustpilot to see what past customers have to say about these clubs.
These types of websites can usually give you a pretty good clue as to whether the wine club is as good as it claims to be, and whether it really is organic or not.
Conclusion
Just because organic wine tends to be a bit niche doesn’t mean you can’t find subscription clubs that offer it. In fact, wine clubs like Winc and Vinesse make organic wine much more accessible to the average drinker. Just remember to remember our tips on choosing a good organic wine club to make sure you pick the right one.
Are you still not sure how to get started with an organic wine club? Leave us a comment and we’ll help you out!
About the author
My name’s Jessica, and I’m a full-time writer and part-time wine lover. I love being able to share expertise through the power of words.
I’m a self-proclaimed wine expert who’s been a patron and member of multiple vineyards. As someone who’s lived in the California Napa Valley and studied wine formally at the university level, I’ve gained a good chunk of knowledge on wine, its origins, and the current market.
I particularly like a good burgundy, but failing that, dry white wine is my go-to. Today you’ll find me sharing my wine expertise with the world. I may or may not have a glass of wine by my desk as I do it.